Guides/Growth Systems

How to report growth to a board or acquirer

A board growth report should fit on one page. It holds five to eight numbers, and each number has its definition, period, source and comparison period written beside it. Under the numbers go a denominator note for the conversion rates, one line on what the numbers can't prove, and the decisions you're asking the board to make.

Most of the board questions I helped prepare for this year came back to a definition, usually the comparison period, the denominator or the attribution rule. Put the definition next to the number and it answers the question before anyone asks. The meeting stays on the decision.

Boards and acquirers will both check your growth story against the records. At Newfold Digital / Bluehost, my VP-level work included board-facing reporting built with the GM, Sales and Finance. At Ziff Davis, I helped acquire and integrate three Black Friday properties in two years. I also built and sold an agency. Each time, someone outside marketing had to be able to inspect the evidence.

The one-page board growth report

Here's the template. Keep the numbers your board already knows, swap in your own definitions, and cut any row you can't source. Eight is the ceiling.

NumberDefinitionPeriodSourceComparison period
1. Qualified leads against planRecords that met the written SQL rule, after spam removalQuarter to dateCRM, pulled after the weekly cleanupPlan for the same period, and the trailing 90 days
2. Qualified lead to opportunity rateOpportunities from the leads that entered in the period (cohort)Leads created in the quarter, read once all have been workedCRM stage datesSame cohort one quarter earlier, and plan
3. New pipeline by sourceOpportunity value by original source, using the written exceptionsQuarterCRM and the attribution rule documentPrior quarter
4. Win rateClosed won divided by all closed, for opportunities created in a fixed earlier windowOpportunities created two quarters backCRMSame window a year earlier
5. Average deal sizeClosed-won value divided by closed-won countQuarterFinance's revenue fileTrailing four quarters
6. Pipeline mixShare of pipeline value outside the entry product or segmentQuarterCRMStart of the year
7. Market demandCategory search demand and third-party intent, separate from your share of itTrailing 16 monthsSearch Console, ad platforms, review site intentSame months a year earlier
8. Paid media returnClosed-won value from campaigns traced to customers, per dollar of paid mediaTrailing two quartersAd platforms joined to CRMPrior two quarters

Below the table go three short blocks.

Download the template (Markdown, with the blank page and the filled example).

A filled example

This is one quarter from a B2B client's board cycle, anonymized and reduced to ratios, with the decision we prepared to ask for. It's what the page looked like before the fixes described below, so it includes an in-period rate the template now avoids.

NumberResultHow it was definedComparison
Qualified leads against plan113 to 115% of goalBooked meetings, after spam removalPlan. Trend shown as the last 90 days against January, at the CEO's request
Qualified lead to opportunity rate45 to 48% (plan 50%)In-period: opportunities created divided by leads created in the quarter. About 41 leads from the last month were still openPlan. Cohort view to follow once the open leads were worked
Non-brand search growth+28% quarter over quarterNon-brand search, as the team reported itPrior quarter
Entry product share of pipeline value54% in January, 45% in MarchCRM pipeline by productStart of the quarter
Market demandNot reported that quarterAdded later in the year, when 16 months of search data showed the category flatSame months a year earlier

Denominator note. The conversion rate is in-period, and about 41 leads created late in the quarter were still open. The rate will rise as they're worked.

What this can't prove. Less than half of direct traffic was really direct, so growth in brand search and direct visits can't be credited to any one channel.

Decision requested. Coming out of a quarter ahead of plan, approve a paid search increase for the ad groups that still had room to grow, plus a test budget for the free assessment offer, which was expected to convert better than the guides and checklists.

Put the definition beside the number

For each number, say whether it's a count, a financial result, an attribution estimate or a forecast, and show when a definition changed. In HubSpot, that means protecting the date each record entered each stage. At the same client, a board slide carried search metrics the analyst couldn't trace to a source, and the same figure could be pulled several ways. That's why the source column exists.

The comparison period is a definition too. The CEO in the example asked that we stop showing year-over-year growth, because the prior year had been weak and made every comparison look better than the business was. The last 90 days against a fixed starting month gave a fairer read, and the comparison column says so.

The denominator problem is the one I'd fix first. The board view divided opportunities created in the quarter by leads created in the quarter, so leads from the last few weeks sat in the denominator with no chance to reach the numerator. That put the conversion rate a few points under plan. The internal view used different math, so the two disagreed. The fix was one method across both views, with any in-period rate labeled with the count of leads still open. A cohort rate is slower to report, but it doesn't punish a strong final month.

What boards asked this year

Boards don't always ask marketing to cut. At one client, the board asked whether a large further increase in paid media could be spent well, and asked for spending scenarios for next year's plan. My answer depended on saturation, meaning whether the next dollar would reach new buyers or buy the same ones at higher prices. At another client we had already seen spend stop scaling with volume, with the extra budget going to lower-quality placements. At the first client, the limit turned out to be the bidding goal more than the budget. The useful report showed, by channel, where the next dollar would go and what it was expected to return.

Other boards want the case for every dollar. At one client, the board asked for the remaining paid spend to be justified from the bottom up ahead of its next meeting, and the CEO's view was that the board needed to see the work behind the number. The paid search case shows how we built that justification from closed deals.

Some boards expect growth the market doesn't have. At one client, leadership was planning for about 50% growth next year while sixteen months of search data showed the category flat. The company had been taking share in a market that wasn't growing. We proposed reporting three measures separately: an estimate of total market demand, the company's share of attention in that market, and how much of the demand it captured. That's row 7 in the template. When the first measure is flat, the board should expect less from the third.

Show what the evidence can't establish

A channel appearing in a deal history doesn't prove it caused the win. A revenue increase during an integration doesn't isolate the integration's effect. One line on the page saying what the numbers can't prove keeps that limit next to the claim, where the reader will see it.

Don't debut a new measure in the meeting where you use it to justify a decision, because the discussion turns into a debate about the measure. At one company, a new win-rate analysis came out of the deal data a week before the board memo was due. The CEO hadn't seen it, and the leader presenting held it back until it could be broken down further. New numbers go in an appendix first.

Decisions requested

End the page with the decisions, each in one sentence. Name the option you recommend, what it costs as a share of the budget, and which number on the page will show whether it worked. A request like approving a paid search increase for specific ad groups, or holding a lower run rate for two quarters while the conversion rate from qualified lead to customer is tracked, gives the board something to approve or reject. A general request to keep investing in brand is much harder to vote on.

Keep the business-unit economics visible

The Ziff Davis portfolio earned money through affiliate commerce, advertising and media partnerships, and the report should keep each revenue path separate. For a portfolio, give each business unit its own column on the page and show how the columns roll up. A portfolio P&L needs the finance team's definitions and allocations, and a combined growth percentage can't show whether an integration worked.

Limits of a one-page board report

A marketing readout isn't a financial audit or a diligence package. The financial definitions belong to finance, and legal and transaction advisers handle their own parts of the process. The example above comes from one sales-assisted B2B company, and none of the examples here supply retention benchmarks.

Common questions

Do we need this if we aren't selling the company?

Yes, because a report another leader can check is useful for budget decisions and board meetings long before any sale. If a sale process does start, you also won't have to rebuild the history under a deadline.

Should we show year-over-year growth?

Only if the prior year is a fair base. One CEO asked us to stop showing it because the prior year had been weak and flattered every comparison. We used the last 90 days against a fixed starting month instead. Whatever you pick, write it in the comparison column so the board knows.

How many numbers belong on the page?

Five to eight. Each one needs a definition you can say in a sentence and a source someone else can pull. If a number needs a paragraph to explain, it belongs in the appendix until the board has seen it a few times.

Who signs off on the definitions?

Finance owns the financial definitions, such as bookings and revenue. Marketing and sales operations own the funnel definitions, and they should come from the same stage definitions document the teams use every week. The CEO signs off on the comparison periods.

Read Audience growth across a portfolio of sites.

About Mark

Mark Barrera runs Mark Barrera Consulting LLC in Austin, Texas. His experience includes audience and review generation at TrustRadius and portfolio integration at Ziff Davis. At Newfold Digital, his work included board-facing reporting. He built and sold an agency. He also served as president of SMC Dallas, and as chairman and president of DFWSEM, the Dallas-Fort Worth Search Engine Marketing Association.